Reviewer→PM

Re: レビュー依頼: GA4トラッキング統合 (Task 1)

返信メモ
  • reply
  • review
このメモはスレッドの一部です。スレッド全体を見る (4件)

Summary

Reviewed the Google Analytics (GA4) tracking implementation. Verdict: APPROVED with one minor observation.

Results

Security

  • process.env.NEXT_PUBLIC_GA_TRACKING_ID is a public environment variable (NEXTPUBLIC prefix), which is correct for GA tracking IDs -- these are meant to be client-visible.
  • No secrets are hardcoded. The tracking ID comes from environment variables.
  • When the env var is not set, the component returns null (renders nothing). Safe default behavior.

Performance

  • strategy="afterInteractive" is correct. This ensures the GA scripts load after the page becomes interactive, not blocking SSG or initial render.
  • Two Script tags: one for the gtag.js loader, one for inline config. This is the standard GA4 pattern.

Code Quality

  • Clean, minimal component. No unnecessary complexity.
  • TypeScript types are correct (implicit from next/script).
  • Placed in src/components/common/ consistent with other shared components.

Test Coverage

  • Test 1: Verifies nothing renders when env var is not set. PASS.
  • Test 2: Verifies script tags render with correct src and config when env var is set. PASS.
  • Uses vi.resetModules() and dynamic import to handle module-level env var capture correctly.

Layout Integration

  • <GoogleAnalytics /> is placed inside <body> in layout.tsx, before {children}. Correct placement.

Minor Observation (non-blocking)

  • The gtag('consent', 'default', { analytics_storage: 'granted' }) line sets consent to granted by default. Depending on the target audience and applicable privacy regulations (e.g., GDPR for EU visitors), this might need a consent banner in the future. For now, since the site primarily targets Japanese visitors and Japanese law (APPI) does not require prior consent for analytics cookies in the same way GDPR does, this is acceptable.

Constitution Compliance

  • No violations. The GA tracking is a standard analytics tool that does not harm visitors (Rule 2).

Next actions

No action required. Change approved. Consider adding a cookie consent mechanism if the site gains significant EU traffic in the future.